The Benefits of an Air Source over a Ground Source Heat Pump System for Your Property
Table of contents
- Air source vs Ground source heat pump: Cost advantages and grant support
- Simpler and quicker installation
- Planning and space considerations
- Efficiency and performance in practice
- Property fit and retrofit ease
- Household comfort and operation
- Wider benefits for homes and the UK
- Air-source heat pump systems trump ground heat pump units
- FAQ
In line with the UK’s net-zero future goals, heat pumps are gaining interest as the eco-friendly, more economical alternative to traditional gas boilers. While homeowners have the options as to the type of heat pump, we explain in this article why an air source heat pump might be more beneficial for your property over a ground source heat pump.
Air source vs Ground source heat pump: Cost advantages and grant support
Both the installation of air and ground source heat pumps are eligible for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS), a financial grant of up to £7,500 for homeowners living in England and Wales. However, there is a great divide between their upfront costs, making the ground source heat pump more expensive, even despite the grant.
While an air source heat pump costs around £11,000, a ground source heat pump costs around £29,000. This cost difference lies mainly in the complexity of their installation, with the air-source heat pump needing just a well-ventilated outdoor space and larger radiators or underfloor heating to work. Meanwhile, ground-source heat pumps require significant groundworks, like laying down underground pipes.
Taking these capital expenditures and similar grants into context, it is safe to say that air source heat pumps pose a stronger payback compared to ground source heat pumps.
Simpler and quicker installation
Not all residential properties can install a ground source heat pump. Interested homeowners must have the extra outdoor space (like a garden) for the underground pipes, which need to be drilled into the ground 2 meters deep through horizontal trenches, or even deeper if opting for vertical boreholes.
Either of these processes is expensive and disruptive, and would take weeks to complete.
This is a huge contrast to air source heat pump systems like EcoFlow PowerHeat, which can be easily added to a house—even a flat or an apartment—as long as you have an outdoor space big enough to hold the compact heat pump itself. What could only extend its completion to a few days: the upgrades to larger radiators or the addition of underfloor heating.
Planning and space considerations
Considering the groundworks they require, ground source heat pumps are better suited to large gardens, rural plots, or shared ground loops. On the other hand, air source heat pumps suit small plots, terraces, and urban homes, more so following the permitted development changes in England effective May 2025.
Before, homeowners needed to be mindful of the one-meter boundary between neighbors when installing an air source heat pump. But now, the government has given homeowners permission to install a heat pump even if it will be placed less than one meter from a neighbor, a bid to further encourage more people to shift to heat pumps.
Also included in these changes are the consent to use larger unit sizes and install up to two units on detached homes.
Schedule Your Free Consultation Today!
What type of house is it?
Residential
Commercial
Flexible Investment
Start small with a 5kWh battery pack and expand as your energy needs grow
15-Year Warranty
15 years of worry-free battery reliability
Personalised Advice
Receive dedicated guidance at every step from your advisor
EcoFlow Residential Ecosystem
Unlock more savings with EcoFlow's suite of home residential products
Efficiency and performance in practice
In winter, ground source heat pumps become a steady, reliable source of heat, since the ground provides stable heat throughout the year, unlike outdoor air which cools with the weather. For instance, while air temperatures may plummet to freezing, the ground remains at a relatively mild 8°C to 12°C. Because of this, this heat pump achieves a higher Seasonal Performance Factor (SPF) or Seasonal Coefficient of Performance (SCOP).
But in mild weather, say spring or autumn, an air source heat pump can become more efficient than its ground-based counterpart. Primarily, because the ground is still at its relatively cool, stable temperature, and the ground source heat pump must still expend energy to circulate fluid through its ground loop, which the air source heat pump does not require because of its straightforward process.
Ultimately, the overall efficiency and performance of any heat pump system are decided by a well-designed setup. This includes matching the system's capacity to the property's heat loss, ensuring the emitter area (e.g., radiators or underfloor heating) is large enough to operate at a low temperature, and correctly setting the heating curve to provide just enough heat for the home's needs.
Property fit and retrofit ease
If you have no plans for a total property upgrade, then the air-source heat pump systems like EcoFlow PowerHeat is the more ideal option.
No extensive groundworks involved, just upgrading of radiators or installing underfloor heating on top of fixing your compact outdoor unit in a space with sufficient airflow. This makes it ideal for existing properties, including terraced houses with limited outdoor space.
But if you are building a property anew or are in the middle of a major property overhaul, then it would not be too demanding to have a ground source heat pump installed. Since either horizontal trenches or vertical boreholes are required for its installation, see to it that you are ready for the costs, the disruptive process, and the timeframe.
Household comfort and operation
Heat pumps, no matter which type, operate on low flow temperature. This means that they deliver steady, consistent heat for long periods while being low on energy consumption.
Whether you choose an air source heat pump or a ground source heat pump, you have the flexibility to pick your indoor heating system. Either you upgrade your existing radiators to larger versions, which better cater to the low-temperature water generated by your heat pump, or you retrofit your home with underfloor heating, which is designed to operate at these low temperatures while providing an even, consistent warmth across a large surface area.
In terms of household comfort, PowerHeat also has an integrated inverter technology, which allows your heating system to ensure constant temperature throughout your home. You can also have full visibility and control of your home heating through the EcoFlow app. From scheduled heating/cooling to your heating energy data, the app lets you manage and monitor your household efficiently.
Wider benefits for homes and the UK
Beyond personal household benefits in the form of long-term savings and household resilience, switching from gas boilers to heat pumps supports a larger cause.
For one, the use of electricity instead of gas to generate heat aligns with European climate goals, such as those outlined in the REPowerEU plan. The plan ultimately aims at reducing reliance on fossil fuels, as well as upholding the UK’s goal of grid decarbonisation.
While both air and ground source heat pumps are beneficial in their own ways, the former is more accessible to UK homeowners, since it requires less space and smaller upfront costs, especially with financial grants from the government.
Air-source heat pump systems trump ground heat pump unitsConsidering spatial and financial requirements, air source heat pumps are easily the more accessible option for most UK households. However, ground source units still have their significant benefits. To know which system is best for your home, you can schedule a consultation and consider your options.
Air-source heat pump systems trump ground heat pump units
Considering spatial and financial requirements, air source heat pumps are easily the more accessible option for most UK households. However, ground source units still have their significant benefits. To know which system is best for your home, you can schedule a consultation and consider your options.
FAQ
Which is better, an air or ground source heat pump?
Ground source heat pumps are more efficient in cold weather, but they’re expensive and complex to install. Air source models are cheaper and easier to install and work best in mild climates. The choice depends on personal situation and preference.
Do heat pumps work in cold weather?
Yes, they do. Heat pumps don't create heat; they move it from one place to another. There's always thermal energy to extract, even at freezing temperatures. Modern heat pumps are designed to operate effectively in temperatures as low as -25°C.
How often should you service a heat pump?
Having your heat pump checked by a professional once a year is a good start. However, some professionals recommend a twice-yearly service. Once in the spring to prep for the cooling season and again in the fall for the heating season.
